Tuesday
Nov182008
House Committee grills Paulson, Bernanke on bailout decisions
The House Committee on Financial Services held a hearing on "Oversight of Implementation of the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 and of Government Lending and Insurance Facilities; Impact on Economy and Credit Availability" on Tuesday in which they questioned Secretary of Treasury Henry Paulson, Federal Reserve Board Chairman Ben Bernanke and Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation Chairman Sheila Bair.
“At this point, public confidence in what we have done so far is lower than anyone would have wanted it to be,” said Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA), “it is essential that we do something to use some of the TARP’s (Troubled Asset Relief Program) funds” to stop the tide of foreclosures in the country. Chairman Frank and other Democrats were critical of how Secretary Paulson had decided to use some of the $700 billion bailout money to buy preferred stocks in banks rather than buy “toxic assets” for which Congress initially called for.
Paulson defended his position by arguing that the best way to save the credit market was by injecting cash directly into banks. “It is very, very important to stay with the purpose of the TARP,” said Paulson. “This is all about protecting the financial system, avoiding collapse, and recovery.”
“At this point, public confidence in what we have done so far is lower than anyone would have wanted it to be,” said Chairman Barney Frank (D-MA), “it is essential that we do something to use some of the TARP’s (Troubled Asset Relief Program) funds” to stop the tide of foreclosures in the country. Chairman Frank and other Democrats were critical of how Secretary Paulson had decided to use some of the $700 billion bailout money to buy preferred stocks in banks rather than buy “toxic assets” for which Congress initially called for.
Paulson defended his position by arguing that the best way to save the credit market was by injecting cash directly into banks. “It is very, very important to stay with the purpose of the TARP,” said Paulson. “This is all about protecting the financial system, avoiding collapse, and recovery.”
Tearing into TARP
“If there’s one thing I regret, I regret attempting to be cooperative in providing to treasury the flexibility to deal with out economic crisis,” said Rep. Maxine Waters (D-Calif.) during a House Financial Services Committee on “Oversight Concerns Regarding Treasury Department Conduct of the Troubled Assets Relief Program”.
“We don’t have any systematic way to help homeowners modify these loans, the treasury has refused to use the dollars to buy up the non performing assets, and the money has basically gone as equity investments in banks who are not putting the money back out so that our consumers can have access to credit,” the Congresswoman said.
Acting Comptroller General Gene Dodaro of the Government Accountability Office recounted recommendations from a recently issued report, including the need for the Treasury Department to limit executive compensation and confirming that the use of funds complies with the legislation “To date, Treasury hadn’t finalized their strategy for monitoring these very important initiatives.”
Neel Kashkari, the Interim Assistant Secretary of the Treasury for Financial Stability, appeared before the committee and defended many of the Treasury Departments decisions.
Essentially dismissing the allegations of a inadequate oversight, Kashkari discussed the formation of the Oversight Board the, the law required the first [Oversight] board meeting to take place within fourteen days. We moved very quickly, and the Oversight Board met within four days...The law requires the Board to meet once a month, but it has already met five times in the just two months since the law was signed.”
Kashkari also defended the choice to offer financial aid to healthy banks, “if we have a dollar, and we give this one dollar to a healthy bank or gave that same dollar to a failing bank, the healthy bank is in a much better position to turn around and make new loans...they’re the ones who are in the best position in this time of economic disruption to step up and make new loans.”
The Assistant Secretary said that this choice would help restore confidence overtime.